Vol. 3 · pages 351–355
Philosophy of Hinduism; Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Ancient India; Buddha or Karl Marx
This text was extracted automatically from the official PDF of Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar: Writings and Speeches, so it may contain small errors. Always check the original page before quoting.
PDF page 351 (printed page 338)
338 DR. BABASAHEB AMBEDKAR : WRITINGS AND SPEECHES
It is really an understatement to say that according to Manu the
Brahman is a lord of all creation. For Manu gives a warning to the
effect that :—
IX. 317. A Brahmana, be he ignorant or learned, is a great divinity,
just as the fire, whether carried forth (for the performance of a burnt
oblation) or not carried forth, is a great divinity.
IX. 319. Thus, though the Brahmans employ themselves in all (sorts)
of mean occupations, they must be honoured in every way; (for each of)
them is a very great deity.
Being a deity the Brahmin is above law and above the King. Manu
directs :—
VII. 37. Let the King, after rising early in the morning, worship
Brahmans who are well versed in the threefold sacred science and learned
(in polity), and follow their advice
VII. 38. Let him daily worship aged Brahmans who know the Veda
and are pure……….
Finally Manu says :
XI. 35. The Brahman is (hereby) declared (to be) the creator (of the
world), the punishcr, the teacher, (and hence) a benefactor (of all created
beings); to him let no man say anything unpropitions, nor use any harsh
words.
In the Code of Manu there are rules regarding the different occupations
which the different orders are required to follow:
I. 88. To Brahmens he (Swayambhu Manu) assigned the duties of reading
the Veda, of teaching it, of sacrificing, of assisting others to sacrifice,
of giving alms, if they the rich, and if indiquent, of receiving of gifts.
I. 89. To defend the people, to give alms, to sacrifice, to read the Veda,
to shun the allurements of sensual gratifiction, are, in a few words, the
duties of a Kshatriya.
I. 90. To keep herds of cattle, to bestow largeness, to sacrifice, to read
the scriptures, to carry on trade, to lend at interest, and to cultivate
land are prescribed or permitted to a Vaishya.
I. 91. One principal duty the supreme Ruler assigns to a Shudra; namely,
to serve the before mentioned classes, without depreciating their worth.
I.74. Let such Brahmans as are intent on the means of attaining the
supreme Godhead, and firm in their own duties, completely perform, in
order, the six following acts:
X. 75. Reading the Vedas, the teaching others to read them, sacrificing,
and assisting others, to sacrifice, giving to the poor if themselves have
enough, and accepting gifts from the virtuous if themselves are poor, are
the six prescribed acts of the first born class;
PDF page 352
339
THE MORALS OF THE HOUSE
X. 76. But, among those six acts of a Brahmin, three are his means
of susbsistence; assisting to sacrifice, teaching the Vedas, and receiving
gifts from a pure handed giver.
X. 77. Three acts of duty cease with the Brahman, and belong not to
the Kshatriya; teaching the Vedas, officiating at a sacrifice, and, thirdly,
receiving presents.
X. 78. Those three are also (by the fixed rule of law) forbidden to the
Vaisya; since Manu, the Lord of all men, prescribed not those acts to
the two classes, military and commercial.
X. 79. The means of subsistence, peculiar to the Kshatriya, are bearing
arms, either held for striking or missile, to the Vaisya, merchandize,
attending on cattle, and agriculture but with a view to the next life,
the duties of both are alms giving, reading, sacrificing.”
Besides prescribing rank and occupation Manu grants privileges to
certain orders and imposes penalties on certain orders.
As to privileges those relating to marriage may be referred to first.
Manu says :
III. 12. For the first marriage of the twice born classes, a woman
of the same class is recommended but for such as are impelled by
inclination to marry again, women in the direct order of the classes
are to be preferred :
III. 13. A Sudra woman only must be the wife of a Sudra; she and
a Vaisya, of a Vaisya; they two and a Kshatriya, of a Kshatriya; those
three and a Brahmani of a Brahman.
Then there are privileges relating to occupations. These privileges
stand out quite prominently when Manu deals with the question as to
what a person is to do when he is in distress:
X. 81. Yet a Brahmen, unable to subsist by his duties just mentioned,
may live by the duty of a soldier; for that is the next in rank.
X. 82. If it be asked, how he must live, should he be unable to get
a subsistence by either of those employments; the answer is, he may
subsist as a mercantile man, applying himself in person to tillage and
attendance on cattle.
X. 83. But a Brahman and a Kshatriya, obliged to subsist by the acts
of a Vaisya, must avoid with care, if they can live by keeping herds, the
business of tillage, which gives great pain to sentient creatures, and is
dependent on the labour of others, as bulls and so forth.
X. 84. Some are of opinion, that agriculture is excellent, but it is a
mode of subsistence which the benevolent greatly blame, for the iron
mouthed pieces of wood not only wound the earth, but the creatures
dwelling in it.
PDF page 353 (printed page 340)
340 DR. BABASAHEB AMBEDKAR : WRITINGS AND SPEECHES
X. 85. If through want of a virtuous livelihood, they cannot follow
laudable occupations, they may then gain a competence of wealth by
selling commodities usually sold by merchants, avoiding what ought to
be avoided.
X. 86. They must avoid selling liquids of all sorts, dressed grain, seeds
of tila, stones, salt, cattle, and human creatures.
X. 87. All woven cloth dyed red, cloth made of sana, of cshuma-bark,
and of wool, even though not red; fruit, roots, and medicinal plants.
X. 88. Water, iron, poison, flesh-meat, the moon-plant, and perfumes
of any sort; milk, honey, butter milk, clarified butter, oil of tila, wax
sugar, and blades of cusa grass;
X. 89. All beasts of the forest, as deer and the like, ravenous beasts,
birds, and fish; spirituous liquors, nili, or indigo, and lascha, or lac; and
all beasts with uncloven hoofs.
X. 90. But the brahmen-husbandman may at pleasure sell pure tilaseeds for the purpose of holy rites, if he keep them not long with a
hope of more gain, and shall have produced them by his own culture.;
X. 91. If he apply seeds of tila to any purpose but food, anoiting, and
sacred oblations, he shall be plunged, in the shape of a worm, together
with his parents, into the ordure of dogs.
X. 92. By selling flesh-meat, lac or salt, a Brahmen immediately sinks
low; by selling milk three days, he falls to a level with a Sudra.
X. 93. And by selling the other forbidden commodities with his own
free will, he assumes in this world, after seven nights, the nature of a
mere Vaisya.
X. 94. Fluid things may, however, be bartered for other fluids, but
not salt for anything liquid; so may dressed grain for grain undressed,
and tila-seeds for grain in the husk, equal weights or measures being
given and taken.
X. 102. The Brahmen having fallen into distress, may receive gifts
from any person whatever; for by no sacred rule can it be shown, that
absolute purity can be sullied.
X. 103. From interpreting the Veda, from officiating at sacrifices, or
from taking presents, though in modes generally disapproved, no sin is
committed by priests in distress; for they are as pure as fire or water.
Compare with this what Manu has to say with regard, to what the
other Varnas can do in an emergency, Manu says :
X. 96. A man of lowest class, who through covetousncss. lives by the
acts of the highest, let the king strip of all his wealth and instantly
banish.
PDF page 354
341
THE MORALS OF THE HOUSE
X. 97. His own office, though defectively performed, is preferable
to that of another, though performed completely; for he, who without
necessity discharges the duties of another class, immediately forfeits
his own.
X. 98. A mercantile man, unable to subsist by his own duties, may
descend even to the servile acts of a Sudra, taking care never to do
what ought never to be done; but, when he has gained a competence,
let him depart from service.
X. 99. A man of fourth class, not Finding employment by waiting
on the twice born, while his wife and son are tormented with hunger,
may subsist by handicrafts.
X. 121. If a Sudra want a subsistence and cannot attend priest, he
may serve a Kshatriya; or, if he cannot wait on a soldier by birth, he
may gain his livelihood by serving an opulent Vaisya.
X. 122. To him, who serves Brahmens, with a view to a heavenly
reward, or even with view to both this life and the next, the union of
the word Brahmen with his name of servant will assuredly bring success.
X. 123. Attendance on Brahmens is pronounced the best work of Sudra;
whatever else he may perform will comparatively avail him nothing.
X. 124. They must allot him a fit maintenance according to their
own circumstances, after considering his ability, his exertions, and the
number of those, whom he must provide with nourishment.
X. 125. What remains of their dressed rice must be given to him,
and apparel which they have worn, and the refuse of their grain, and
their old household furniture.
X. 126. There is no guilt in a man of the servile class who eats leeks
and other forbidden vegetables; he must not have the sacred investiture;
he has no business with the duty of making oblations to fire and the
like, but there is no prohibition against his offering dressed grain as
a sacrifice, by way of discharging his own duty.
X. 127. Even Sudras, who were anxious to perform their entire duty,
and, knowing what they should perform, imitate the practice of good
men in the household sacraments, but without any holy text, except
those containing praise and salutations, are so far from sinning, that
they acquire just applause.
X. 128. As a Sudra, without injuring another man, performs the
lawful acts of the twice-born, even thus, without being censured, he
gains exaltation in this world and in the next.
X. 129. No superfluous collection of wealth must be made by a
Sudra, even though he has power to make it, since a servile man,
PDF page 355 (printed page 342)
342 DR. BABASAHEB AMBEDKAR : WRITINGS AND SPEECHES
who has amassed riches, becomes proud, and, by his insolence or neglect,
gives pain even to Brahmens.
He concludes :—
X. 130. Such, as have been fully declared, are the several duties of the
four classes in distress for subsistence, and, if they perform them exactly,
they shall attain the highest beatitude.
The privileges to some were not merely social they were also financial,
Says Manu :—
VIII. 35. From the man, who shall say with truth, ‘This property, which
has been kept, belongs to me’, the king may take a sixth or twelfth part,
for having secured it.
VIII. 36. But he, who shall say so falsely, may be fined either an eighth
part of his own property, or else in some small proportion to the value of
the goods falsely claimed, a just calcultion having been made.
VIII. 37. A learned Brahmen, having found a treasure formerly . hidden,
may take it without any deduction; since he is the lord of all.
VIII. 38. But of a treasure anciently deposited under ground, which any
other subject or the king has discovered, the king may lay up half in his
treasury having given half to the Brahmens.
IX. 323. Should the king be near his end through some incurable disease,
he must bestow on the priests all his riches, accumulated his kingdom to
his son, let him seek death in battle, or if there be no war, by abstaining
from food.
VII. 127. Having ascertained the rates of purchase and sale, the length
of the way, the expenses of food and of condiments the charges of securing
the goods carried, and the net profits of trade, let the king oblige traders
to pay taxes on their saleable commodities.
VII. 128. After full consideration, let a king so levy those taxes continually
in his dominions, that both he and the merchant may receive a just
compensation for their several acts.
VII. 129. As the leech, the suckling calf, and the bee, take their natural
food by little and little, thus must a king draw from his dominions an
annual revenue.
VII. 130. Of cattle, of gems, of gold and silver, added each year to the
capital stock, a fiftieth part may be taken by the king; of grain, an eighth
part, a sixth, or a twelfth, according to the difference of the soil, and the
labour necessary to cultivate it.
VII. 131. He may also take a sixth part of the clear annual increase
of trees, fleshmeat, honey, clarified butter, perfumes, medical substances,
liquids, flowers, roots, and fruit.