Vol. 8 · pages 231–235
Pakistan or the Partition of India
This text was extracted automatically from the official PDF of Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar: Writings and Speeches, so it may contain small errors. Always check the original page before quoting.
PDF page 231 (printed page 206)
206 DR. BABASAHEB AMBEDKAR : WRITINGS AND SPEECHES
was completely checked forever. Still the countries they
conquered between 1326 and 1683 formed a vast empire. A
few of these territories the Turks had lost to their enemies
thereafter, but taking the extent of the Turkish Empire as it
stood in 1789 on the eve of the French Revolution, it comprised
(1) the Balkans, south of the Danube, (2) Asia Minor, the
Levant and the neighbouring islands (i.e., Cyprus), (3) Syria
and Palestine, (4) Egypt, and (5) North Africa from Egypt to
Morocco.
The tale of the disruption of the Turkish Empire is easily
told. The first to break away de facto, if not de jure, was
Egypt in 1769. The next were the Christians in the Balkans.
Bessarabia was taken by Russia in 1812 after a war with
Turkey. In 1812 Serbia rebelled with the aid of Russia and
the Turks were obliged to place Serbia under a separate
government. In 1829 similar concessions were granted to two
other Danubian provinces, Moldavia and Wallachia. As a result
of the Greek war of independence which lasted between 182229, Greece was completely freed from the Turkish rule and the
Greek independence was recognised by the Powers in 1832.
Between 1875-77 there was turmoil amongst the Balkans. There
was a revolt in Bosnia and Herzegovina and the Bulgarians
resorted to atrocities against the Turks, to which the Turks
replied with atrocities in equal measure. As a result, Serbia
and Montenegro declared war on Turkey and so did Russia.
By the Treaty of Berlin, Bulgaria was given self-government
under Turkey and Eastern Rumania was to be ruled by Turkey
under a Christian Governor. Russia gained Kars and Batoum.
Dobrudja was given to Rumania. Bosnia and Herzegovina were
assigned to Austria for administration and England occupied
Cyprus. In 1881 Greece gained Thessaly and France occupied
Tunis. In 1885 Bulgaria and Eastern Rumania were united
into one state.
The story of the growth and decline of the Turkish Empire
upto 1906 has been very graphically described by Mr. Lane
Poole in the following words * :—
“In its old extent, when the Porte ruled not merely the narrow
territory now called Turkey in Europe, but Greece, Bulgaria and
* Turkey, pp. 363-64.
PDF page 232 (printed page 207)
207PAKISTAN : LESSONS FROM ABROAD
Eastern Rumania, Rumania, Serbia, Bosnia and Herzegovina,
with the Crimea and a portion of Southern Russia, Egypt,
Syria, Tripoli, Tunis, Algiers and numerous islands in the
Mediterranean, not counting the vast but mainly desert
tract of Arabia, the total population (at the present time)
would be over fifty millions, or nearly twice that of Europe
without Russia. One by one her provinces have been taken
away. Algiers and Tunis have been incorporated with France,
and this 175,000 square miles and five millioon inhabitants
have transferred their allegiance. Egypt is practically
independent, and this means a loss of 500,000 miles and
over six millions of inhabitants. Asiatic Turkey alone has
suffered comparatively little diminution. This forms the
bulk of her present dominions, and comprises about 680,000
square miles, and over sixteen millions of population. In
Europe her losses have been almost as severe as in Africa
where Tripoli alone remains to her. Serbia and Bosnia are
administered by Austria and thereby nearly 40,000 miles
and three and a half millions of peoples have become
Austrian subjects. Wallachia and Moldavia are united in the
independent kingdom of Rumania, diminishing the extent of
Turkey by 46,000 miles and over five millions of inhabitants.
Bulgaria is a dependent state over which the Ports has no
real control and Eastern Rumania has lately de facto become
part of Bulgaria and the two contain nearly 40,000 square
miles, and three millions of inhabitants. The kingdom of
Greece with its 25,000 miles and two million population
has long been separated from its parent. In Europe where
the Turkish territory once extended to 230,000 miles, with
a population of nearly 20 millions, it now reaches only the
total of 66 thousand miles and a population of four and a
half millions. It has lost nearly three-fourths of its land,
and about the same proportion of its people.”
Such was the condition of Turkey in 1907. What has befallen
her since then is unfortunately the worst part of her story.
In 1908 taking advantage of the revolution brought about by
the Young Turks, Austria annexed Bosnia and Herzegovina
and Bulgaria declared her independence. In 1911 Italy took
possession of Tripoli and in 1912 France occupied Morocco.
Encouraged by the successful attack of Italy in 1912, Bulgaria,
Greece, Serbia and Montenegro formed themselves into a
Balkan League and declared war on Turkey. In this war, known
as the first Balkan War, Turkey was completely defeated. By
the Treaty of London (1913) the Turkish territory in Europe was
reduced to a narrow strip round Constantinople. But the treaty
could not take effect because the victors could not agree on the
distribution of the spoils of victory. In 1913 Bulgaria declared
PDF page 233 (printed page 208)
208 DR. BABASAHEB AMBEDKAR : WRITINGS AND SPEECHES
war on the rest of the Balkan League and Rumania declared
war on Bulgaria in the hope of extending her territory. Turkey
also did the same. By the Treaty of Bukharest (1913), which
ended the second Balkan War, Turkey recovered Adrianople and
got Thrace from Bulgaria. Serbia obtained Northern Macedonia
and Greece obtained Southern Macedonia (including Salonika),
while Montenegro enlarged her territory at the expense of
Turkey. By 1914 when the Great European War came on,
the Balkans had won their independence from Turkey and
the area in Europe that remained under the Turkish Empire
was indeed a very small area round about Constantinople
and her possessions in Asia. So far as the African continent
is concerned, the Sultan’s power over Egypt and the rest of
North Africa was only nominal; for the European Powers had
established real control therein. In the Great War of 1914
the overthrow of Turkey was complete. All the provinces
from the Mediterranean to the Persian Gulf were overrun,
and the great cities of Baghdad, Jerusalem, Damascus and
Alleppo were captured. In Europe the allied troops occupied
Constantinople. The Treaty of Sevres, which brought the war
with Turkey to a close, sought to deprive her of all her outlying
provinces and even of the fertile plains of Asia Minor. Greek
claim for territory was generously allowed at the expense of
Turkey in Macedonia, Thrace and Asia Minor and Italy was
to receive Adalia and a large tract in the South. Turkey was
to be deprived of all her Arab provinces in Asia, Iraq, Syria,
Palestine, Hedjaz and Nejd. There was left to Turkey only
the capital, Constantinople, and separated from this city, by
a “ neutral zone of the straits,” part of the barren plateau
of Anatolia. The treaty though accepted by the Sultan was
fiercely attacked by the Nationalist Party under Kamal Pasha.
When the Greeks advanced to occupy their new territory, they
were attacked and decisively beaten. At the end of the war
with Greece, which went on from 1920 to 1922, the Turks
had reoccupied Smyrna. As the allies were not prepared to
send armies to help the Greeks, they were forced to come
to terms with the Nationalist Turks. At the conference at
Mudiania the Greeks agreed to revise the terms of the Treaty
of Sevres, which was done by the Treaty of Lausanne in 1923
PDF page 234 (printed page 209)
209PAKISTAN : LESSONS FROM ABROAD
which granted the demands of Turkey except in Western
Thrace. The rest of the Treaty of Sevres was accepted by the
Turks which meant the loss of her Arab provinces in Asia.
Before the War of 1914, Turkey had lost all her provinces
in Europe. After the War, she lost her provinces in Asia. As
a result of the dismemberment of the old Turkish Empire,
what now remains of it is the small state called the Republic
of Turkey with an area which is a minute fraction of the
old Empire.*
II
Take the case of Czechoslovakia. It is the creation of
the Treaty of Trianon which followed the European War
of 1914. None of the peace treaties was more drastic in its
terms than the Treaty of Trianon. Says Prof. Macartney,
“By it Hungary was not so much mutilated as dismembered.
Even if we exclude Croatia, Slavonia, which had stood only
in a federal relationship to the other lands of the Holy
Crown—although one of eight hundred years’ standing—
Hungary proper was reduced to less than one-third (32.6
per cent.) of her pre-war area, and a little over two-fifths
(41.6 per cent.) of her population. Territories and peoples
formerly Hungarian were distributed among no less than
seven states.” Of these states, there was one which did not
exist before. It was a new creation. That was the state of
Czechoslovakia.
The area of the Republic of Czechoslovakia was 54,244
square miles and the population was about 13,613,172. It
included the territories formerly known as Bohemia, Moravia,
Slovakia and Ruthenia. It was a composite state which
included in its bosom three principal nationalities, (i) Czechs
occupying Bohemia and Moravia, (ii) Slovaks occupying
Slovakia and (iii) Ruthenians in occupation of Ruthenia.
Czechoslovakia proved to be a very short-lived state. It lived
exactly for two decades. On the 15th March 1939 it perished or rather
was destroyed as an independent state. It became a protectorate
of Germany. The circumstances attending its expiry were
*The area of Turkey is 294,492 square miles exclusive of 3,708 square miles
of lakes and swamps. The area of Turkey in Europe is only 9,257 square miles.
PDF page 235 (printed page 210)
210 DR. BABASAHEB AMBEDKAR : WRITINGS AND SPEECHES
of a very bewildering nature. Her death was brought about
by the very Powers which had given it birth. By signing the
Munich Pact on 30th September 1938—of which the protectorate
was an inevitable consequence, Great Britain, France and
Italy assisted Germany, their former enemy of the Great War,
to conquer Czechoslovakia, their former ally. All the work of
the Czechs of the past century to gain freedom was wiped off.
They were once more to be the slaves of their former German
overlords.
III
What are the reasons for the disruption of Turkey ?
Lord Eversley in his Turkish Empire* has attempted to
give reasons for the decay of Turkey, some internal, some
external. Among the internal causes there were two. First the
degeneracy of the Ottoman dynasty. The supreme power fell
into the hands either of the Vazirs of the Sultans or more often
in the hands of women of the harem of the Sultan. The harem
was always in antagonism to the official administration of the
Porte, which ostensibly carried on the administration of the
state under the direction of the Sultan. The officials of every
degree from the highest to the lowest were interested in the
sale of all offices, civil and military, to the highest bidders.
For securing their object, they found it expedient to bribe the
inmates of the harem and thereby win the assent of the Sultans.
The harem thus bacame the centre from which corruption
spread throughout the Turkish Empire and which was one of
the main causes of its decay. The second main cause of the
decadence of the Turkish Empire was the deterioration of its
armies due to two causes. During the last 300 years the army
had lost the elan and the daring by which the Ottomans won
their many victories in the early period of their career. The loss
of this elan and daring by the Turkish army was due to the
composition of the army, recruitment to which was restricted to
Turks and Arabs, and also to the diminution of opportunities
of plunder and the hope of acquiring lands for distribution
among the soldiers as an incentive to victory and valour
* See abridgment by Sheikh Abdur Rashid.